Super Soft White Sandwich Bread

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

This post contains affiliate links. Read our disclosure policy.

Similar Posts

22 Comments

  1. Hi
    I tried this recipe today,I actually made this in to buns.
    I am just amazed with the results.its really too good.
    So soft fluffy and tasted so well.
    Thank you for sharing

  2. I made this recipe today and oddly, the loaves are kind of sunk in on the sides. Everything else seems fine. I’m a seasoned baker and have made tons of sandwich bread. I used instant yeast. I’m not entirely sure what causes this. I am also in AZ so the only thing I can think of is perhaps overproofed due to a warm kitchen, but it didn’t appear that way before baking. Got plenty of oven spring. Oh well, I think it’s going to taste amazing!

    1. Hi Megan,

      It’s hard to say what might be the problem without seeing your loaves, but my initial question is…what size pans did you use? In the post, I suggest a standard size loaf pan which is 8-1/2×4-1/2×2-1/2 inches. If your pan is bigger than that, you most likely will not have as fluffy as a loaf as it will bake outwards instead of upwards. The only other thing I can think of is overproofing, which can cause the loaf to collapse or sag after coming out of the oven.

  3. Have you ever made this with the Food nanny commute flour? It seems to be better for my family that has issues with gluten. Do you have any suggestions what I could do if using that flour instead?

    1. I have not made this with Kamut flour, but you could definitely give it a try. You may notice that you don’t need as much flour in the final mixing. Let me know how you like it!

  4. Hi,
    I am just now making this recipe, and it seems like the metric measurements are not correct on some of the ingredients, when compared to the US measurements?
    example: I measured out 1 Tbls of instant yeast, and it weighed 9 grams, which is the weight you have listed for the 2 Tbls of yeast?
    These other ingredients are off too, just not as much as the yeast.
    Butter, salt, bread flour
    The sugar and the milk seem to be fine.
    I am going to use the US measurements, as hopefully, this is what the others used that made this and were happy with the outcome.
    Please advise as to which is correct.
    Thanks!

    1. Hi Jeanette,
      When measuring by volume (US measurements), results can very, from baker to baker. This is why I also include metric measurements too. Weighing your ingredients will insure that you are replicating the recipe exactly how it was written. I always encourage bakers to weigh ingredients for the best possible results.

  5. I only have active dry yeast. Can I use that instead of instant yeast? If so, how do I use it? Do I do anything different? The is my first attempt at bread & I’ve never used either product.

    1. Oh yay! I’m so excited for you! Yes you can use active dry yeast! With instant yeast, you can just add it straight to the recipe. But with active dry yeast, you need to activate it first before adding to the recipe. You can sprinkle it into the milk and let it sit for about 10 minutes to make sure it bubbles up. Wait as long as 15 minutes – if nothing happens, it’s probably yeast that needs to get replaced. If it does bubble up, go ahead and add that mixture to the recipe and continue to mix as directed. Let me know how it goes! You can read more about yeast in this article: https://thatbreadlady.com/active-dry-yeast-vs-instant-yeast/

  6. Is it possible to bake these loaves in disposable aluminum pans? If so, would there be any changes to the baking?

    1. You definitely can. Just make sure they’re the right size. They might bake faster on the bottoms since the foil is thinner. I’d try baking one loaf first to test it out before committing your entire batch to it. Maybe place the foil pans on top of a baking sheet to keep the bottoms from getting too brown. Check the loaves 5 minutes earlier to see how they’re doing. Let me know how it turns out.

      1. 5 stars
        Thanks! I ended up just buying actual loaf pans 🙂 It turned out amazing! Reminded me of a brioche loaf. Is there a big difference between this and brioche?

  7. 5 stars
    So yummy my family loves this recipe! I was wondering when doubling the recipe, how long should it be kneading for? I have a Bosch mixer. I tried doubling the recipe and kneading took over an hour to achieve the window pane test. Trying to double so that I freeze vs baking so often.

    1. Hi Jordana,
      Oh wow that’s quite a long time for kneading. I’d probably say about 10-12 minutes. Have you made a single batch? I’m curious how long you knead for a single. Also, if you don’t get completely to window pane, it’s ok. As long as it’s close. You want your dough to feel cohesive and soft – it shouldn’t easily tear. Also remember, the gluten will continue to develop during the first rise too – so the texture will feel quite different after. It will be much easier to handle. So glad your family enjoyed this recipe. Keep me posted on your next bake!❤️

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating